New Delhi: The Supreme Court on October 7 upheld a government notification not to tax companies
doing business in India if they were registered in Mauritius.
Setting aside a Delhi High Court judgement, which had quashed the April 13, 2000 notification, a Bench
comprising Justice Ruma Pal and Justice B N Srikrishna said the Delhi High Court had erred in quashing
the notification.
On the basis of Double Taxation Avoidance Treaty between India and Mauritius, the Union government
had issued the notification, saying if the Mauritius government gives residency certificate to a company
doing business in India, then the same company will not be taxed by Income Tax authorities in India.
Allowing the appeal of the Union government, the Bench said the April 13, 2000 notification was valid
and legal.
The petitioner organisation, Azadi Bachao Andolan, had contended that nearly 50 per cent of India's
foreign investment comes through companies registered in Mauritius, where they are not even allowed
to do business or own property.
It had alleged that these companies, merely because of being registered in Mauritius, should not be
allowed a tax holiday as their main business and income was from India.
The Delhi High Court, while accepting the plea of Azadi Bachao Andolan, had said even if a firm was
registered in Mauritius, the Income Tax officials can lift the foreign corporate veil and find out whether it
was actually a foreign company or not.
The petitioners had alleged that these unscrupulous firms were taking advantage of the Double
Taxation Avoidance Treaty between India and Mauritius and have effectively translated it into no
taxation treaty.
PTI