Tokyo: Japan will explain to its partners in the Group of Eight (G8) most
industrialised nations, a tax reform programme to stimulate its economy this
weekend, but economists are unsure it will be implemented because of divisions in
the government and ruling coalition.
Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi last week told the government to proceed with major
tax reforms to boost consumption and investment, as part of a broader fight against
the deflation plaguing the world's second largest economy.
The government's Tax Commission is to submit its plan of tax reforms for the next
financial year starting in April 2003 to Koizumi on June 14, hours before the
opening of the two-day meeting of G8 Finance Ministers in Halifax, Canada.
However, Economists said the three main sources for the reform proposals were at
odds over which measures to take. The three groups putting together the reform
programme are the ruling Liberal Democratic Party (LDP), Tax System Research
Council, the government's Tax Commission, linked to the finance ministry, and the
Council on Economic and Fiscal Policy (CEFP), which reports to Koizumi.
"The goals of the three groups are completely different. The CEFP focuses on using
the tax system as a tool of economic revival, the Commission focuses on using the
system as a revenue tool, and the LDP is using the tax system as a political tool, "
explained Robert Feldman, Managing Director of Morgan Stanley in Tokyo.
Feldman said he only expected results in the few areas where the three camps did
agree."Modest investment tax credits, some changes in inheritance tax and gift tax,"
he predicted, but said but no tax cuts would be introduced before the 2003 financial
year.
Koizumi has stipulated that the reforms should be introduced from the next fiscal
year, not earlier, and be completed by March 2007. But MPs from the LDP are calling
for tax cuts to be introduced this year, according to party Secretary General, Taku
Yamasaki.
The new tax, which is expected to hit small companies hard, would be politically
difficult to implement, according to Murashima. "The package today looks more like
deflationary measures."It is tax revenue neutral with mid to long-term tax hikes not
cuts. Today's tax cut is tomorrow's tax hike," said Shigenori Okazaki, Political
Analyst at UBS Warburg.
Murashima pointed out that, Japanese corporate taxes have already been significantly
reduced, slashed from 50 per cent to 40.87 per cent over the past decade.