New Delhi: Attorney General Soli Sorabjee is understood to have told the government
in the matter relating to Reliance's eligibility to participate in PSU disinvestment
that a CBI complaint was different from a chargesheet and that the corporate could
not be disqualified.
Disinvestment Ministry said in an internal note, prepared after consultation with
AG, that "to the extent that the complaint relates to offences that are not related
to the security and integrity of the country, the complaint itself would not have
the effect of disqualifying a company."
The Secretary's note on the issue of CBI filing complaint against Reliance and three
of its officials under the Official Secrets Act, said, "AG also drew my attention to
a distinction that has been obscured in our guidelines. He pointed out that
a 'complaint' - whether by an individual or by a organ of the government - is
strictly speaking different from chargesheet."
Unlike a complaint, a chargesheet is one that has been framed by a court of law and
judicial mind has been exercised.
"This is an ambiguity which we will have to deal with at some stage," sources
quoting the note said.
CBI has filed complaint in a local court against Reliance and three of its employees
under Section 5(2) and 5(4) of the Officials Secrets Act which do not deal with
espionage and passing on of documents relating to national security.
The guidelines for disqualifying a company from bidding for buying government stake
in a PSU require that "for disqualification on the ground of non-security related
offences, there must in fact be, inter alia, a conviction by a country of
law."
PTI